If you eat keto and want a beanless white chicken chili, I make this one in the Instant Pot. Green chiles and diced tomatoes cook with the chicken thighs. My favorite part is shredding the chicken right in the creamy broth. A bowl has 6.5 g net carbs before toppings.
I make this white chicken chili anytime I’m craving something warm, spicy and creamy. It’s always a tough call between this and my keto taco soup. In this pot I like the way the diced green chiles and tomatoes taste with the shredded chicken. There’s enough broth to eat it with a spoon, but I still set out pork rinds for scooping.
The Instant Pot is my pick after work. I can cook the thighs, shred them and finish the chili in the same liner. If I’m starting dinner in the morning, I use the slow cooker. And if both appliances are put away, a stockpot works too. The biggest difference on the stove is when I add the cream cheese.
For toppings, I like avocado, shredded cheese, cilantro and a squeeze of lime. If you’re serving two pots of chili, my beef chili goes well alongside it.
No beans, just 6.5 g net carbs per bowl
Cauliflower rice takes the place of the beans in this recipe. I use 1 1/2 cups of it for the whole pot. I let the chicken cook first so I can pull the thighs apart in the broth, then stir in the rice. It gives you little pieces of cauliflower between the shreds of chicken in each spoonful.
One batch makes six bowls. Each has 8.4 g total carbs, 6.5 g net carbs and 30.8 g protein before toppings. That includes the tomatoes, the green chiles and both kinds of dairy. If you add extra cheese or avocado, count those separately.
Why I keep the tomatoes in white chicken chili
I use diced tomatoes in this chili because they add acidity and depth to the broth. A whole 14.5-ounce can goes in with the chicken and a 4.5-ounce can of green chiles. Cumin, oregano and chili powder season the broth as the thighs cook. What makes this a white chili is the creamy broth around those pieces of tomato.
I stir 2 tablespoons of heavy cream into the broth at the start. Then I cut an 8-ounce block of cream cheese into 6 to 8 pieces and spread them around the chicken before closing the lid. I leave the cream cheese in pieces at this point. It blends in when I shred the chicken.
Planning dinner around the Instant Pot timer
My 15-minute timer starts when the pot comes to pressure. At the beep, I give it another 10 minutes to release pressure naturally, then vent the rest. I use that time to get the toppings ready. Once I open the lid, I check the thickest thigh for 165°F before shredding. If it needs longer, I pressure cook it a few more minutes and check again.
For a morning start, the slow cooker takes 3 to 4 hours on high or 6 to 8 hours on low. I give the cauliflower rice the last 20 minutes in the pot. On the stove I wait until the thighs reach 165°F to stir in the cream cheese. In the pressure cooker the cream cheese has been in there with the chicken from the start.
My trick for shredding chicken in the pot
I shred the chicken right in the pot using an electric mixer. That saves me transferring hot chicken to a cutting board and washing another dish. The beaters pull apart the thighs while the softened cream cheese mixes into the broth around them. Two forks work, too. Once the chicken is shredded, I stir in the cauliflower rice and give it about 2 minutes in the hot Instant Pot before serving.
Making a freezer meal for another night
I don’t always have time for full meal prep. For this chili I can bag the uncooked chicken and broth ingredients together and freeze the bag flat for up to 3 months. I keep the cauliflower rice separate so I can add it at the end, the same way I do with a fresh pot.
Thaw the bag in the refrigerator before cooking. I save the avocado, cilantro and lime for serving. If what you want is a single bowl to take out for lunch, it’s easier to freeze individual portions after the chili is cooked.
How to store and reheat this chili
Divide leftover chili into shallow containers and refrigerate promptly. I keep it in the fridge for up to 4 days. For one serving I use the microwave. For a few bowls I warm the chili on the stove. Heat leftovers to 165°F throughout, then finish each bowl with the toppings you like.
How to make this creamy chili
3 ways to cook this chili
Pick the method that works for your schedule. I’ve made this all three ways and they all produce the same creamy broth.
Pressure Cooker Method
The Instant Pot is my preferred method for this chili. Everything goes in one pot, and dinner is ready in about 25 minutes.
Add all the chili ingredients and spread the cubed cream cheese on top. Pressure cook on high for 15 minutes, then let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes. Shred the chicken with a hand mixer right in the pot and stir in the cauliflower rice.
Add all the chili ingredients, including the cream cheese, to the crock pot first thing in the morning. Cook on low for 6 to 8 hours. When you get home, shred the chicken, and add the cauliflower rice about 20 minutes before you eat. I prefer the taste of the slow cooker version when I have the patience for it. The long cook time builds a deeper, rounder flavor in the broth.
Stove Top Method
Add all the chili ingredients to a stock pot except the cream cheese and cauliflower rice. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to low. Cover and let simmer for 30 minutes or until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165 degrees. Stir in the cream cheese until melted and creamy, then shred the chicken right in the pot. Add the cauliflower rice and let it heat through for about 2 minutes.
Add chicken thighs, chicken broth, diced tomatoes, green chiles, heavy cream and seasonings to the liner of the Instant Pot. Stir to combine.
For this step
Chicken thighs
Chicken broth
Diced tomatoes
Green Chiles
Heavy Cream
Chili powder
Salt
Dried parsley
Cumin
Garlic powder
Onion powder
Dried oregano
Black pepper
2
Pressure cook
Spread cubed cream cheese around the chicken chili broth mixture. Secure the Instant Pot lid and set the valve to seal. Pressure cook on high for 15 minutes. Let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes before releasing the remaining pressure manually by turning the valve to vent. Check the thickest thigh with a food thermometer; it must reach 165°F before shredding. Pressure cook a few minutes more if needed.
For this step
Cream cheese
3
Shred chicken
Shred chicken using an electric mixer or two forks.
4
Add cauliflower rice
Add cauliflower rice. Let set for 2 minutes until cauliflower rice is heated through.
For this step
Cauliflower rice
5
Slow cooker instructions
Add the chicken broth, diced tomatoes, diced chiles and seasonings to the liner of a slow cooker. Mix to combine. Add in chicken thighs and cream cheese. Cover and cook on high for 3 to 4 hours or low for 6 to 8 hours. Check the thickest thigh with a food thermometer for 165°F. Cook longer if needed. Twenty minutes before you want to eat, add in cauliflower rice.
For this step
Avocado (optional)
Limes (optional)
Cheese (optional)
Cilantro (optional)
Nutrition
Per serving: 1 bowl
Calories
352
Fat
20.2g
Protein
30.8g
Total carbs
8.4g
Net carbs
6.5g
Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the ingredients listed. Brands vary, so check labels if you track closely.
Can I shred the chicken without an electric mixer?
Yes. I use two forks to pull the cooked thighs apart right in the liner. My hand mixer saves me a little work because it shreds the chicken and blends the softened cream cheese into the broth in the same pass. With forks, I stir the broth and shredded chicken together before the cauliflower rice goes in.
Can I use frozen cauliflower rice?
Yes. I use fresh or frozen cauliflower rice, and I add it after I shred the chicken. The broth is still hot, so I stir in the rice and let it sit for about 2 minutes. I check that it’s hot all the way through before I ladle it into bowls. In the slow cooker I give it longer and stir it in about 20 minutes before serving.
I found it this chili has a much better texture if you make this recipe by substituting boiled peanuts for the cauliflower (as long as you can eat peanuts). The boiled peanuts gives it the real texture of chili. 1-lb. of shelled boiled peanuts has a lower total carb and a lower net carb count than 1-lb of cauliflower rice.
Delicious! I had rotisserie chicken meat to use up and was looking for ideas. So glad I found your recipe and site. Based on comments, I used 1.5 tsp of cumin plus I threw in 1/2 a small sweet onion, finely chopped. So happy to have some for the freezer. We will definitely make this again. Thank you!
White chili has a reputation for being watered-down next to a red, and I went in skeptical. What makes this one different is the cream cheese ratio, it thickens the broth without tasting like chicken soup. The green chiles punch through the dairy and keep it tasting like actual chili. I’d push the cumin by a half teaspoon next time, but that’s preference, not a fix.
25 minutes is about right for the IP. I always underestimate how much the cauliflower rice thickens the broth once it softens in there, on top of the cream cheese.
Every time I add cream cheese to a hot liquid it breaks on me, so I went in fully expecting a grainy mess (had a backup plan and everything). Broth came out completely smooth though, thick and even. 6.5 net carbs for a bowl like that. Not bad.
I had that exact thing happen to me for years before I figured out what keeps it from breaking here. I cut the cream cheese into 6 to 8 pieces and spread them around the pot instead of dropping in one block, and the fat from the heavy cream helps hold it together too. The other half of it is the shredding step. When I drop the electric mixer right into the liner, the cream cheese gets whipped into the broth while the chicken shreds, so there’s nothing left sitting there ready to seize. Glad you never had to use that backup plan, Angela!
Work potluck last week and I’m still getting texts about it (one came in while I was sitting here writing this, which, hello). Made it the night before and actually panicked when I saw how thick it got in the fridge, but it warmed back up smooth. The cauliflower rice was the thing, a few people kept saying the texture was different from other chilis in a way they couldn’t quite name, and I ended up explaining the whole keto-no-beans situation to four people over a bowl of soup, which was not on my agenda. My coworker who is very skeptical about anything labeled ‘healthy’ just stood over the pot with her bowl and said ‘what did you put in this’ in the most serious tone. I genuinely didn’t know where to start.
What did you put in this is the best chili review I’ve heard. When it gets thick in the fridge, Lorraine, that’s just the cream cheese thickening as it cools.
Never thought to use a hand mixer to shred chicken but it took 45 seconds and I’ll never go back to two forks. Does the slow cooker version get that same thick broth, or is that an Instant Pot thing?
Same thick broth in the slow cooker. That creaminess is all the cream cheese, not the IP. I add the pieces in the last 30 minutes and stir a couple times until it melts smooth.
Made this Sunday and my wife, who never touches anything I make when I’m ‘eating healthy,’ asked what I put in the broth. I told her cream cheese and she didn’t believe me.
Swapped half the cream cheese for goat cheese and the tang it adds to the broth is something else. It melts a little differently, sharper and more interesting. If you have some sitting around, try it.
My mom used to make white chicken chili every fall, the old-fashioned kind with a can of white beans and sour cream stirred in at the end. I’ve been keto for three years and mostly made peace with not having it. Found this version last week and made it on a rainy Tuesday night without expecting much. The cream cheese broth has that same depth her version had, and the shredded chicken thighs fell apart the same way. I sat with my bowl for a while after.
That rainy Tuesday detail got me. The cream cheese does something to the broth I didn’t fully plan when I first made this, that slow thick depth. Glad it took you back.
My husband has a rule about dinner needing rice or bread with it, it’s not negotiable, so I honestly wasn’t sure how this was going to go. He ate the whole bowl and then wanted to know what I did to the broth (the answer is cream cheese, which he would have said no to if I’d asked first). Something about the way it gets silky and thick got him. Four stars because I think I rushed the seal on my Instant Pot and mine came out thinner than it probably should have been, but I’m making it again this week to fix that.
The cream cheese confession never gets old. Thin broth in the IP is almost always the valve, needs to be fully clicked to sealing before the timer starts.
My mom made white chicken chili every fall and I kind of just stopped hoping for it when I went keto, like it was just something I had to let go. Made this last Sunday and when the cream cheese started melting into the broth and that cumin smell hit, I don’t know, I was back in her kitchen for a second. The chicken thighs came out falling apart tender. Four stars because I let my cauliflower rice sit too long and it got a little soft (totally my fault, not the recipe), but this is the one I’ll keep coming back to.
The cumin and cream cheese moment gets me every time I make this. For the cauliflower rice, I pull mine when it’s still a little underdone because it keeps cooking in the hot broth. Two to three minutes max.
My husband inhaled his bowl and went back for more without saying a word, which from him is louder than any compliment. I’d probably ease up on the cumin just a touch next time, but the cream cheese broth is freaking unreal.
Made this Tuesday when it was brutal outside and I needed something that would actually warm us up, and my son, who has vetoed every ‘healthy’ chili I’ve put in front of him since we went keto, went back for a second bowl without saying anything and then asked me to save him the leftovers for school lunch. That’s the thing with this one, the cream cheese broth is so thick and rich it doesn’t register as diet food to anyone who isn’t looking for it. I used the slow cooker, had it going by 9am, and the chicken thighs were falling apart by dinner, I just shredded them with a fork in about 30 seconds flat. My only note is I’d go heavier on the green chiles next time, maybe a full can and a half, because we like heat and it needed a nudge. Four stars from me but honestly four and a half if that were an option.
When the kid who vetoes every healthy dish saves the leftovers for school lunch, you’re done arguing. Slow cooker thighs are perfect for this. They just shred themselves.
352 calories and 6.5 net carbs for a bowl this filling is hard to beat. I skipped the tomatoes to drop the carbs a bit more and it was still plenty flavorful with the green chiles and cumin.
I made this for the first time today with boneless chicken breasts (only had about a pound) and skipped the green chiles since I didn’t have any. Still turned out so good. Can’t wait to try it again with the chiles next time.
Nice! The chiles add a little kick and some depth, so definitely try it next time. I usually go with one can if my family’s eating it, two if it’s just me and my husband.
Nice! The green chiles add a good kick, but the chili still works without them. If you want that little bit of heat next time without the chiles, I sometimes throw in a pinch of cumin and a dash of cayenne.
Solid recipe. The cream cheese makes it really rich which I liked but my wife thought it was too heavy. Next time I’ll cut the cream cheese to 6 oz and see how that goes.