These keto ice cream sandwiches are my small-batch freezer treat for a chocolate-cookie craving. Thin cocoa cookies hold a creamy ice cream center, with 5.5g net carbs per sandwich. This recipe makes just two, and I shape the filling so it fits the cookies.
I came up with these keto ice cream sandwiches because I wanted a frozen treat I could pull out any night of the week. This recipe makes exactly two, with thin chocolate cookies and a layer of keto ice cream cut to fit between them. The combination takes me straight to that classic summer treat, with a chocolate cookie on each side and a cold, creamy center.
I make the chocolate cookies from scratch and use store-bought keto ice cream to keep the filling simple. There are two parts to plan around, cooling the baked cookies and refreezing the shaped ice cream. Once both are ready, assembly is straightforward. I like having the finished sandwiches wrapped in the freezer for whenever I want one.
What goes into the chocolate cookies
I use a mixture of almond flour and coconut flour with a little unsweetened cocoa powder for the chocolate flavor. The dough also has monkfruit blend sweetener, two egg yolks, softened unsalted butter, vanilla and a pinch of salt. Everything mixes together in a small bowl with a fork.
Almond flour and coconut flour absorb moisture differently, so changing that combination changes the dough you’re rolling. Measure both flours, use softened butter and include both yolks. Mixing the ingredients evenly before rolling helps avoid pockets of dry flour in these thin cookies.
I tested multiple versions before I landed on this formula. The goal was a cookie with the right balance of crispness and softness to sandwich around ice cream. I use the yolks for a chewy texture and leave the whites out to help keep the cookies flat. I leave out baking powder and baking soda and prick the dough before baking to help it stay flat.
Choosing the ice cream
I partnered with Keto Pint for this recipe and used their ice cream for the filling. You can use another keto-friendly ice cream you enjoy. The batch uses ½ cup, which is shaped into a slab before cutting. Check the label when choosing a flavor, since ingredients and nutrition vary by brand.
I also have homemade vanilla ice cream, chocolate, strawberry and mocha ice cream recipes that work for the filling. Choose the flavor you want with the cocoa cookies. Chocolate on chocolate gives you that familiar ice cream sandwich combination, while vanilla gives you a lighter-flavored center.
The nutrition estimate is for one of the two sandwiches, with 5.5g net carbs, 11.2g protein and 421 calories. That includes both the cookies and filling. Changing the ice cream or cookie ingredients changes that estimate, so use your chosen ingredients when calculating a variation.
How I shape the ice cream layer
I soften the ice cream in the refrigerator for 2–3 hours. The microwave’s defrost function is another option. Stop once it is soft enough to transfer into the lined dish. I recommend a semi-soft-serve consistency because it takes less time to refreeze. Liquid ice cream also works in this method, though it needs time to solidify again.
Line a small square or rectangular container with parchment paper, then pour or scoop in the softened ice cream. Choose a container that gives you a layer about ½–1 inch thick. With only ½ cup of ice cream, the size of the container matters. A wide dish spreads that small amount into a thinner layer.
I put the shaped ice cream back in the freezer until it is solid. This gives me a flat slab to cut into pieces that fit the cookies.
How I roll and bake the cookies
I mix the cookie ingredients with a fork until the dough is evenly combined, then place the dough ball between two sheets of parchment paper. I slide a damp paper towel underneath the bottom sheet to keep the parchment from moving across the counter. Roll the dough to ⅛ inch thick, keeping the thickness even so the cookies bake consistently.
I shape the dough into a rough square before rolling so I can cut out the cookies with less rerolling. I use a square cookie cutter for matching shapes. A knife or pizza cutter also works for squares or rectangles, and you can make circles if you prefer. Keep the size and shape consistent so you can use the same outline when cutting the ice cream.
Place the cookies on a parchment-lined baking tray and prick them with a fork. That step helps them bake flat. Bake at 325°F for 8–10 minutes. These cookies are very delicate while hot, so I let them cool completely on the baking tray before gently lifting them. They firm up as they cool and become easier to handle for assembly.
Assembling the sandwiches
Once the ice cream has refrozen, I cut it into pieces to fit the cooled cookies. Using the same cutter for the cookies and ice cream makes lining them up straightforward. If you used a knife for the cookies, match those dimensions when cutting the frozen slab.
I sandwich the ice cream between the cookies and wrap each finished sandwich in parchment or wax paper. Put the wrapped sandwiches into a freezer-safe bag and keep them in the freezer. Individual wrapping makes it easy to take out one when you want it.
Planning ahead and making a larger batch
The hands-on prep is about 10 minutes, and the cookies bake for 8–10 minutes. The refrigerator method also needs 2–3 hours to soften the ice cream, followed by refreezing. Allow time for the baked cookies to cool completely. Refreezing time depends on how soft the ice cream became, so use a solid slab as your cue for assembly.
I keep this recipe small for portion control, but you can double or triple it for more sandwiches. Scale all the ingredients together and keep the cookie dough and ice cream layer at the same thicknesses. Use additional trays or containers as needed, then wrap the finished sandwiches individually for freezer storage.
A vanilla-cookie variation
For vanilla cookies, I leave out the cocoa powder. The vanilla extract is already in the dough, and this gives you another way to pair the cookies with your favorite frozen filling. Keep the remaining ingredients and the rolling, baking and cooling method the same.
Melt the ice cream in the refrigerator for 2-3 hours until soft. Can also defrost in the microwave. Once soft or liquid, pour into a small parchment lined baking tray. Use a container that will ensure a 1/2 to 1 inch thickness of ice cream. Then refreeze.
2
Make cookie dough
Add almond flour, coconut flour, sweetener, cocoa powder, 2 egg yolks, butter, vanilla and salt to a small bowl. Mix together with a fork until a dough forms and is evenly incorporated.
3
Roll cookie dough and cut out cookies
Place dough ball in between two sheets of parchment paper. Using a rolling pin, roll out to ⅛ inch thick. Cut into square or rectangle shape using a knife, cookie cutter or pizza cutter.
4
Bake cookie sandwiches
Place cookie on a parchment lined baking tray. Prick dough with a fork. Bake at 325 degrees for 8-10 minutes. Let cool completely before handling.
5
Cut the ice cream and form sandwiches
Once ice cream is refrozen, cut into a shape to fit the cookies. Sandwich the ice cream in between the cookies. Store wrapped in parchment or wax paper and store in the freezer in a freezer safe bag.
Nutrition
Per serving: 1 ice cream sandwich
Calories
421
Fat
37.8g
Protein
11.2g
Total carbs
16.4g
Net carbs
5.5g
Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the ingredients listed. Brands vary, so check labels if you track closely.
How do I keep the cookies flat enough for sandwiches?
Pricking the dough with a fork is the detail that makes the difference here. I found that it helps the cookies stay flat as they bake. I also leave out baking powder and baking soda. The dough includes two egg yolks, and I roll it to ⅛ inch so the cookies are thin enough for a sandwich.
How soft should the ice cream be before shaping?
I recommend a semi-soft-serve consistency. It is soft enough to scoop into the lined container, and it takes less time to refreeze than fully melted ice cream. I spread it into a layer ½–1 inch thick, then freeze it solid before cutting. That gives me a slab I can cut to match the cookies.
Can I make vanilla cookies instead of chocolate?
Yes. I leave out the cocoa powder when I want vanilla cookies. I still use the vanilla extract, both flours and both egg yolks. I roll and bake them the same way, then let them cool completely before handling and adding the ice cream.
I usually skip cookie recipes with coconut flour because they always taste dry to me, so I almost didn’t bother here. These came out totally different. Firm but not chalky, and they hold up around the ice cream instead of falling apart.
Freeze the cookies for 10 minutes after they’ve cooled before you sandwich them – if your kitchen runs warm, the ice cream starts going the second it hits the cookie. I grew up eating Good Humor bars every summer, the chocolate-coated ones you’d chip down layer by layer to the vanilla, and I hadn’t thought about them in probably fifteen years until I bit into one of these. Something in the cocoa cookie and cold ice cream put me right back on a porch in July. At 5.5 net carbs I read the label twice. The only thing that bothered me was the two-sandwich batch, which is probably smart, but standing at the freezer knowing there’s one left has a way of ruining the first one. I’ll double the batch next time.
I’m so glad the Good Humor thing came through, Melissa! And you’re right about doubling, roll the dough on a bigger sheet of parchment and cut four squares instead of two.
The 2-tablespoon cocoa looks minimal. It isn’t. Most keto cookie versions over-sweeten to cover the flour taste and just end up tasting like candy. This one doesn’t. Holds together through the freeze, clean bite at the seam, no crumble. Small batch works fine, four is enough. Four stars because I’d go 30 seconds longer in the oven, but that’s me.
Something about the almond-coconut flour ratio keeps these thin and firm. Every other version I’ve tried either puffs up or goes soft. Two at a time, no sad freezer math.
I’ve been on keto almost two years and kept putting off ice cream sandwiches because I assumed the cookie dough would be a disaster. Figured it would crumble when I rolled it out, or fall apart on the first bite. Made these Saturday and the dough came together fast. Rolling between parchment was cleaner than I expected. What got me was the texture after freezing: the cookies stay just firm enough without turning into a brick you have to gnaw through. Used Rebel, cut rounds with a cookie cutter to match the cookie shapes. Under 6 net carbs for two sandwiches. Already planning a second batch with a different Rebel flavor next weekend.
Cookie cutter rounds are way cleaner than squares, I switched to that too. If you try a different Rebel flavor, mint chip with the cocoa cookie is worth it.
Really good, but let them cool on the rack a full 15 minutes before assembling or they’ll crumble when you press them together. First attempt I rushed it and lost both sandwiches. Worth the patience.
Used peanut butter keto ice cream instead of vanilla and the cocoa cookie kind of amplified it in a weird good way. Mine got a little crumbly at the edges (probably rolled the dough too thin) but worth figuring out.
A couple of things that made these a lot easier to assemble. Lining a small square container with plastic wrap before pressing in the softened ice cream and freezing it solid overnight gives you a clean block that cuts to size without crumbling or squishing. Way more control than trying to work with the original container. Second, I swapped in Rebel chocolate ice cream and the cocoa-on-cocoa combination is worth doing at least once. The cookies baked up crisper than I expected at the 1/4 inch thickness, but that turns out to be what you want since they soften up after assembly in the freezer. Made a batch Friday, they were in perfect condition by Saturday afternoon.
That plastic wrap block is so much cleaner to cut. I’ve just been fighting with the carton every time. And the Rebel chocolate on top of the cocoa cookies, yeah, that makes sense.
Can these cookies be made without the almond flour? I know I’ve had success with subbing in coconut flour before, but that was in recipes only calling for almond flour, not mixed flours.